MultiLink_Newsdesk's take
One day before Election Day, the Justice Department has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to step into its fight with California over voter rolls. The DOJ says it has identified 20,000 "likely" noncitizens on the state's rolls and wants their ballots set aside until citizenship is verified. A federal judge and a divided 9th Circuit panel, including a Trump appointee, rejected the request, warning of a "material risk" of disenfranchising eligible voters and citing the rule that election procedures should not change on the eve of a vote. County officials say many people on the list had no active registration, and a UCLA analysis found 42% of the names are not on the current voter roll, while naturalized citizens also appear on it. Separately, a judge has barred the administration from threatening election officials; that order is under appeal.
Our analysis: Only citizens should vote, and checking voter rolls is a legitimate task. But the timing and method matter. Courts on both sides of the political spectrum found the list unreliable, and freezing ballots while voting is underway risks punishing lawful citizens, including naturalized Americans. When the federal government pressures state officials days before an election, it can damage trust as much as any fraud it claims to fight. Whether the Supreme Court acts, and how fast, will be a key test of its role in elections.
1 comment